Concerning Women Singing or Directing in Church Choirs
Question: What does St Paul mean when he says "Let your women keep silence
in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are
commanded to be under obedience as also saith the law" (1 Corinthians
14:34)? Does this mean that women cannot direct or sing in the choir?
Answer: Interpreting this passage is complicated by
the fact that it is in the context of a discussion of how speaking in tongues
and prophecy were to be handled during the services of the Church, and yet
because of the abuse of these practices by those who were suffering from
spiritual delusion, the Church ceased to allow such things to be done in the
context of the services altogether. Furthermore, because women who claimed to
have the gift of prophecy were very prominent in the Montanist heresy (which
began in the second century), in many of the comments about this passage you
find in the Fathers, they are using it polemically. And so it may be that
polemics led some to take the view that this passage means that women should
refrain not only from speaking in prophecy or singing audibly in the Church,
but even from praying audibly. However, this view was not unanimously held.
St. Paul
said earlier in the same epistle: "But every woman that prayeth or
prophesieth with her head uncovered dishonoureth her head: for that is even all
one as if she were shaven" (1 Corinthians 11:5), and here he makes no
suggestion that they should not pray or prophesy in Church... only that they
should not do so without their heads uncovered. St. John Chrysostom points out:
"For
there were, as I said, both men who prophesied and women who had this gift at
that time, as the daughters of Philip, (Acts 21:9) as others before them and
after them: concerning whom also the prophet spake of old: “your sons shall
prophesy, and your daughters shall see visions” (c.f. Joel 2:28 and Acts 2:17
-- from Homily 26 on 1 Corinthians).
In his
37th homily on 1 Corinthians (which covers 14:34), he says that the prohibition
is directed against women speaking "idly," or
"inconsiderately" (i.e. out of the proper order discussed earlier in
chapter 14), but he does not suggest that the statement prohibits women who had
the gift of prophecy from prophesying in Church.
The
context of chapter 14 is about the proper order that should prevail when people
either spoke in tongues or prophesied... and there is a previous instance in
which St. Paul speaks of keeping silence:
"If
any man speak in an unknown tongue, let it be by two, or at the most by three,
and that by course; and let one interpret. But if there be no interpreter, let
him keep silence in the church; and let him speak to himself, and to God (1
Corinthians 14:27-8).
Clearly
in this case, St. Paul is not making an absolute ban on such a person speaking
in Church -- he is only forbidding him to speak in tongues if there is no one
to interpret (in which case no one else would receive any edification). And so
the silence is with regard to speaking out of good order.
Then St.
Paul again speaks of keeping silent:
"Let
two or three prophets speak, and let the others judge. But if anything is
revealed to another who sits by, let the first keep silent. For you can all
prophesy one by one, that all may learn and all may be encouraged. And the
spirits of the prophets are subject to the prophets. For God is not the author
of confusion but of peace, as in all the churches of the saints" (1
Corinthians 14:29-33).
When it
speaks of letting the others judge, this suggests that after a person would
prophesy, others would comment on it -- most likely this would have been done
by those who had charge of the Church (certainly an Apostle, if present, and
the local bishop, presbyters, and deacons). Probably some would ask questions
about what was said. It is in both of these respects that St. Paul is telling
women to keep silence, and if they had questions to ask their husbands about it
later -- but this meant keeping silence with regard to these specific things.
And St. John Chrysostom's comments about refraining from idle talk were
certainly also applicable here.
Of
course, in our context, we would not allow either a man or a women to speak in
tongues or prophesy in the context of a service, but the point is that the
statement that women should keep silence was not an absolute prohibition
against women praying audibly or singing.
St.
Ephrem the Syrian actually formed women choirs in Edessa (see "Spoken
Words, Voiced Silence: Biblical Women in Syriac Tradition, by Susan Ashbrook
Harvey). According to Fr. Robert Taft (a noted historian of Eastern Liturgics),
there was also a woman's choir in the Hagia Sophia (Interview of Sister Vassa
Larin, "Orthodoxy is not a Religion of Fear").
There are
also long standing traditions of congregational singing, such as among the
Carpatho-Russians, which obviously included women in the singing. And those who
have grown up in that context will tell you that this was one of the most
powerful aspects of parish life.
Furthermore,
women have been singing in mixed choirs and even directing choirs in the
Russian Church for a very long time now, and saints, such as St. John of
Shanghai have not only raised no objections to it, but have blessed it to be
so. So while one may make a case against women singing on the basis of the
comments of some Fathers, the fact that the Church has allowed it, and that this
has been without any controversy, and with the blessing of many saints should
restrain anyone from making dogmatic arguments against the practice.
It is
also a fact that without women singers and choir directors, many parishes would
be hard pressed to pull off a decent service, and so even if you could make the
argument that in an ideal world, choirs would consist of only tonsured male
readers, the problem remains that we do not live in such an ideal world, and
have to use the resources that we have. St. Paul's concern in his first epistle
to the Corinthians was that "all things be done decently, and in good
order" (1 Corinthians 14:40). If our interpretation of his admonitions
leads us to the opposite effect, then I would suggest this means we are
misreading him on some level.
When a
baby girl is baptized, she is Churched. And in that service, the priest brings
her into the middle of the Church and says "In the midst of the church
shall she sing praises unto Thee" (c.f. Psalm 21[22]:22). It is hard to
imagine why we would say this if we did not intend that it should actually
happen.
By Fr. John Whiteford
Source: http://fatherjohn.blogspot.com.by/2015/11/stump-priest-women-singing-in-church.html
